Welcome to Miss Kitty's Pizza & Such
Miss Kitty's Pizza & Such, located at 208 N Norris Ave in New Meadows, ID, is a delightful culinary gem that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Known for its exceptional pizzas, including the highly praised Wyatt Earp, the restaurant emphasizes quality with house-made ingredients and a deliciously balanced crust. Customers rave about the friendly service, attentive owners, and mouthwatering sides like the French onion soup and savory meatball appetizers. The inviting atmosphere and commitment to excellence make Miss Kitty’s a must-visit, whether you’re in for a quick bite or a leisurely meal after exploring the beautiful New Meadows area.
-
208 N Norris Ave, New Meadows, ID 83654, United States208 N Norris Ave, New Meadows, ID 83654, United States Hotline: +1 208-347-2636
Welcome to Miss Kitty's Pizza & Such, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the picturesque town of New Meadows, Idaho, at 208 N Norris Ave. This cozy eatery isn't just a pizza place; it’s a sanctuary for food lovers seeking comfort and quality in every bite.
From the moment you step inside, you'll notice the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff who treat you like family. It's no surprise that owner-operated service shines through every aspect of the dining experience. As one of our patrons, Melissa P, noted, "Food, including salads, were incredible," highlighting the care taken in food preparation here. The menu is a carefully curated selection of hearty options designed to satisfy every palate.
The pizza at Miss Kitty's is the star of the show. Each slice boasts a perfect blend of cheesy goodness that keeps seasoned pizza lovers coming back for more. As Trent Moncur described, the moment he picked up a slice, he knew he was in for a treat—a true testament to the quality that this establishment prides itself on. The restaurant caters to various dietary preferences, featuring a delicious cauliflower crust for those seeking a lighter option.
But pizza isn’t the only highlight. Dive into their pasta dishes, such as the creamy Fettuccine Alfredo or the flavorful Baked Penne, both of which are crafted to perfection. Customer reviews often commend the attention to detail in every dish. Eryka Liberatore remarked on the impressive balance of toppings and the visual appeal, which showcases the passion behind Miss Kitty's culinary creations.
Moreover, the beverage options, like the refreshing Huckleberry Lemonade or the cozy Hot Apple Cider, pair beautifully with the main courses, enhancing your dining experience. The atmosphere is quiet and relaxed, making it a perfect spot to unwind after a day of exploring the stunning New Meadows area.
The community spirit and commitment to quality are palpable within every corner of Miss Kitty's Pizza & Such. Trevor Hill perhaps sums it up best, stating, “THIS IS PIZZA MADE WITH LOVE, THOUGHT AND CARE.” Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this eatery promises to surprise and delight your tastebuds time and time again. Don’t miss your chance to enjoy pizza perfection at this quaint destination!
Owner was our waitress and she was amazing. Food, including salads, were incredible. Yummy cauliflower crust was available, too. Highly recommend!
When I picked up the first slice of pizza, it was so cheesy I was a bit worried about chocking. Then after I took a bite, I decided death by that good of a pizza was worth it. It really was amazing. We were out playing in the beautiful New Meadows area all day and pizza hit the spot. It really was some of the best pizza I’ve had, which says a lot. The staff was friendly and the store was so fun. There is not a ton of options for dinner in New Meadows, but Kitty’s did not disappoint. The wait was a bit long, but to be fair, a bunch of people showed up to eat there at the same time and I would take good quality pizza over quick pizza anytime. If I am ever back in New Meadows again, I will find myself back it that pizza sanctuary! Also, I loved the Wyatt Earp!
We stopped by on our way home from the city for a To-go order. It was our first time being able to order and we heard high things. We were definitely not disappointed. The crust is delicious! A very nice balance of toppings. The attention to quality being sent out is something to be lacking in many places these days but they don’t just send out food to get order done, they actually care about the visual product being served. We will definitely be stopping in again when possible! Excellent service and amazing food!
WOW! This is the best pizza I have ever had in the state of Idaho and I grew up here. So good you’ll eat your crust. Everything is made in house and not haphazardly thrown together. THIS IS PIZZA MADE WITH LOVE, THOUGHT AND CARE. 10/10 recommend SEED OIL SAFE QUALITY INGREDIENTS
Great tasting food, quiet environment with just a handful of tables. Service is great and friendly. Meatball appetizers are full of great flavor!
We just had a great pizza dinner at Miss Kitty’s. A darling restaurant with a Gunsmoke flair. We enjoyed a giant meatball appetizer which was very flavorful, the margarita pizza with Pepperoni on half (added red sauce) and drinks for around 16 per person and I have to say, she could charge more. Pizza by the slice is also sold and quite inexpensive. You could have a great pizza lunch for less than 5. The pizza crust is phenomenal—thin and crisp but not floppy and with great flavor. The toppings were generous and very fresh and plenty of fresh basil on top. Delicious! The huckleberry lemonade was a treat, too. The owner wouldn’t share the crust recipe, lol, so we will have to return on our next trip. The decor is so darling and 80’s country hits playing in the background set the mood. Marshall Dillon would have loved this place!! This is a new restaurant, but the owner is no rookie. She truly hit it out of the park! Even if you have to drive from McCall, totally worth it.
Finally got the chance to dine in at Miss Kitty’s after enjoying their amazing takeout pizzas more than once—and now I understand exactly why this place has such a loyal following. The food is delicious, the vibe is warm and welcoming, and you can just feel the good energy in the air. Miss Kitty herself was my server, and her kindness and care really set the tone. It’s clear that the whole team is happy to be there, and that joy comes through in the food and the experience. So grateful to have a spot like this in New Meadows!
What a lovely little pizza, pasta & salad spot. Make this your stop on the way to or from an increasingly busy McCall. We ordered caprese salad, a special crushed red pepper alfredo pasta, and a personal sized pineapple jalapeno pizza. Everything tasted fresh and we enjoyed each bite! Service was great. We’ll definitely stop here again the next time we visit the area.